iPad – So Close, yet so Far
Thursday, May 13th, 2010In a previous post titled “Computing Among the Clouds” I painted a picture of how personal computing might look like in the future. I have also alluded to the tremendous opportunities that Apple was wasting by not delivering a tablet computer in another previous post. Well, so begins the days of the iPad. These devices are pretty close to what I was envisioning as a “window” to the cloud, with a few exceptions.
I’ve been test driving an iPad for teaching and educational uses and I must say that it is marvelously well designed device. It’s more mobile than any tablet computer I’ve seen thus far and as an iPhone owner, I found it incredibly easy to get going. It works well as a reader and is a great device for consuming media. As applications are launched and the price of the iPad drops and competitors enter the market, a new revolution of computing will begin. But, this does not mark the end of the laptop computer.
The iPad is great, but I think it could be so much better. I have a Macbook, HP Tablet PC, a desktop PC and iPhone. The iPad wouldn’t really replace any of those devices. Yes, I have really enjoyed my iPad user experience and because of this I considered replacing my old Macbook with one, until I begin trying to generate content. The lack of web cam is certainly noticeable. Wouldn’t it be great if you could use Skype with an iPad or create a small home movie and instantly share it with friends and family? Also, the form factor is just a little too big for typing one handed and I can’t rest my hands on the virtual keyboard to touch type. While you can buy a keyboard for one, it constricts you to portrait mode. Even if you used a wireless keyboard, the iPad is still chained to iTunes and the computing experience is very closed down compared to my trusty Macbook or convertible Tablet. This is quite frustrating and goes against the democratic openness ideology that the Internet and Web 2.0 has engendered. Web browsing is limited without flash and the applications I can install are dictated by Apple. I like Apple and all the innovations and amazing user experiences it creates, but this has come with the cost of ownership control. There is a reason why freeing an iPhone or iPad from these restrictions is known as “jailbreaking.” One can only hope that a legitimate competitor will help push for a change in these policies.
The buzz around the HP slate and the possibilities of a Google tablet is proof that this form factor could become mainstream. However, for slate tablets to really reach its potential, I think they need to replace one or more of the devices we use every day. How great would it be if I could just dock my iPad like device and have it replicate a laptop experience with all the freedom to use and install the applications I need to be productive, be entertained, and create content. All of this could be done on a minimized machine with the data in the cloud. This would help prevent data loss should the machine get stepped on. This is the vision I had in “Computing Among the Clouds” I think the iPad is one step closer as it is the best device I’ve seen yet for consuming content. Hopefully healthy market competition will help drive innovation closer to this realization.